home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
Wrap
Text File | 1993-07-01 | 55.8 KB | 1,223 lines
Newsgroups: rec.skate,news.answers,rec.answers Path: senator-bedfellow.mit.edu!bloom-beacon.mit.edu!uhog.mit.edu!eddie.mit.edu!news.intercon.com!udel!gatech!howland.reston.ans.net!ux1.cso.uiuc.edu!moe.ksu.ksu.edu!hobbes.physics.uiowa.edu!news.uiowa.edu!news.weeg.uiowa.edu!adchen From: adchen@umaxc.weeg.uiowa.edu (Tony Chen) Subject: Rec.skate FAQ: In-line Skate reviews (5/8) Message-ID: <rec-skate-faq-5-741560246@umaxc.weeg.uiowa.edu> Followup-To: rec.skate Sender: adchen@news.weeg.uiowa.edu (Tony Chen) Supersedes: <rec-skate-faq-5-740035880@umaxc.weeg.uiowa.edu> Reply-To: adchen@umaxc.weeg.uiowa.edu (Tony Chen) Organization: University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA References: <rec-skate-faq-1-741560246@umaxc.weeg.uiowa.edu> Date: Thu, 1 Jul 1993 20:58:23 GMT Approved: news-answers-request@MIT.Edu Expires: Sat, 31 Jul 1993 06:00:00 GMT Lines: 1205 Xref: senator-bedfellow.mit.edu rec.skate:6555 news.answers:9900 rec.answers:1359 Posted-By: auto-faq 1.24 Archive-name: rec-skate-faq/part5 REC.SKATE FAQ - PART 5: SKATE REVIEWS (last changed May 14, 1993) ================================================================================ IN-LINE SKATE REVIEWS --------------------- (as compiled from alt/rec.skate) NOTE: This collection of "reviews" was culled from articles posted in alt.skate (now defunct) and rec.skate, dating from May 1991. While these articles include many facts and first-hand experience, much of the text here is necessarily opinion. Also realize that the in-line market is changing rapidly, so prices and specifications are likely to be out of date. Table of contents ----------------- Zetras, Riedell, other low-end skates Roller Derbys Bauers California Pro Ultra Wheels Gretzky Wings Switch-It Metroblades Macroblades EQ/ES Aeroblade (Rollerblade) Racing skates Zetras, Riedell, low-end skates ------------------------------- I'd at least consider getting the "Reidell 601 Extreme!" skates (or possibly other Reidell models) over the R-blade Lightnings. Although I haven't tried on a pair, their wheels (Hypers) appear to be far superior to the slow, spongy, Rollerblade Kryptonics 608s that come on the lightnings (though I've heard the version on the TRS are a bit better than those on the regular lightning due to a bigger hub). The one local store I know of here that carries the Reidells (Beacon Hill Skate) sells them for about $175. They look like pretty decent skates. David B Rosen, Cognitive & Neural Systems Internet: rosen@cns.bu.edu ----- Riedell 601 Extremes from Skates On Haight, San Francisco. $175. These have the top clasp/buckle like the Lightning TSR's. The design of the boot was aided by Olson (the founder of Rollerblades). You cannot adjust the height of the wheels like you can on the Lightnings. The wheels are supposedly fast (I say supposedly because I as a beginner can't really say that fer-sure, I can say I did move fair distances without a lot of effort). The boot is supposed to breath better and be better designed than the 608's. I found both the Reidell boot and the 608 to feel the same (in terms of comfort)(standing in the store) I also brought wrist/hand guards (slammers(?)) and knees pads (~$17 ea) and they have already paid for themselves (I've only fallen once so far but when I did it was hard). The help I got in making the decision from SOH was very good. Another place was nice to me was Courtesy Sports in Los Altos ( $179.99 with a 10% back if you find them advertised cheaper). The worst place was Big-5, Stevens Creek, San Jose ("They're more expensive so they have to be better.") Everybodyelse (where I went in person) was imbetween. Nuevo Color (San Mateo) were very nice on the phone (608's $179) Any Mountain and Tri City are not cheap (608's: $185-$199) (even with their sale price) Nobody in this area tended to stock the Baur(?) or the Ultra Wheels Classics mentioned in August Consumer Reports (A lot of people have the Ultra Wheels Skate Attrck 2000's which compared to the Lightnings and the Reidell is *very* uncomfortable), and nobody had their price for the RollerBlade Lightnings. On the personal side, I found the orthopedic pads for my flat feet do help, and that because of my 'knocked-knees' my stance is slightly wider than that of most people I've seen skating, but it really has affected my balance like I thought it would (sometimes I do find myself pushing the outside edges of my feet against the boot). Anyway, all I have to do now is learn how to turn quickly enough to avoid the oncoming brick wall (that probably won't make the Skate boarders happy :)) (SOH also has skate boards). If I didn't get back to you personally, sorry, thanks for all you help and answers, Winston. ----- SonH is still alive and well. SoffH is just their mail-order branch. The only warning about SoH is that there appears to be some bad blood between them and Rollerblade. They will steer you away from Rollerblade products (and, mostly, toward SwitcHit products). They bash Rollerblade's Aeroblade, calling it technically inferior, which is wrong. >I've only ice skated a little, but I've been thinking about buying ice >skates, then I saw SwitcHits. Anybody know if they're OK as ice skates? >I guess they're hockey blades, which I'm not sure I'd want if I'm into >figure skating. The SwitcHit blades indeed have a hockey blade rock. I don't know why they couldn't do figure skate blades, though. You might want to call SwitcHit and ask. They have an 800 number. SwitcHit says that several NHL players have gone with SwitcHit. What these players have done is put SwitcHit blade mounts on their boots. These players don't use SwitcHit's boots. The Consumer Reports one-page article is very good. I think virtually all of their comments are right on target. The main problems were in coverage -- they didn't include Riedell or SwitcHit skates or Rollerblade's Aeroblade in the evaluation. Also, they just mentioned replacement wheels in passing, but didn't mention any particular brands. I believe this thread started with a query about inexpensive Rollerblade mail-order sources. First off, it appears as if most mail-order operations cannot sell the upper part of the Rollerblade line. The dividing line appears to be at the Lightning TRS. If you want the Aero, Racer, or TRS, you may not be able to find it via mail-order. There are limitations on what shops can discount these upper skates, too. I like to support local shops that give good service. You may be able to do some bargaining with a local shop on accessories that you buy along with your skates, etc. Just remember that it costs money to provide good service! If a local shop charges high prices but doesn't give good service, don't support them. It may be useful to tell them why you're going elsewhere. The best ways to get support for local skating is to vote with your $$$ at shops that are doing good things. Phil Earnhardt pae@netwise.com ----- Roller Derby ------------ Just for the sake of expanding our inline horizons 8-) a friend and I headed out to a Pelican sports/pool store out on Rt.22 (in NJ) to scout the non-Rollerblade inline skates. Two main non-RB lines they had available were RollerDerby and Bauer. First the RollerDerbys Sonic2000's ($150 list): Boots cut low in front, but high in back, with laces and a buckle (ala the Lightning TRS) and small wheels (didn't say anywhere, but looked like 70mm,80A) My friend and I didn't even bother trying on these skates after we noticed that the plastic runners with their plastic connecting pins going from the left runner to the right weren't holding the runners very well. We could press each runner inward and the pins would snap in where they should've. South Coast ($250 list): A three-buckle skate, looks lots like the Macroblade, but in a hideous hot-pink (liner)/black (boot)/yellow-n-orange (trim/accents) color combo. Wheels weren't marked again, but looked like 70mm 80A. Spinning the wheels with the skates upside-down gave about 3 or 4 turns, which was pretty surprising. Anyway, the liner was okay, but for some reason in the bottom they were packed with a rubbery insole. After taking them out, we felt much more comfortable in the skates. I'd rate the liners comparable to the TRS's. Although this was an all-buckle skate the buckles looked like they were cast from a cheap mold. A far cry from the buckles on the Aeroblade. But all in all, the buckles held pretty snug. TK4000's ($300 list): Also a three-buckle skate, all black. I assumed the wheels were like those of the other Rollerderbys. Bearings much better than the Sonic2000's. The liners were again packed with the rubber insole, but after removing those, we found that the liners were pretty good, much like the Macros. The buckles still looked cheaply made though. Good snug fit, but still short of the Macros. A moderate skate, but definitely not worth $300. All the Rollerderby skates have a really small brake pad on the right skate. It's only about 3/4 inches thick! The material was really, really hard plastic though, not the rubber kind. As a whole, I'd recommend against buying this brand, if only for the reason that your money would be much better spent on other brands (isn't that the only reason? 8-) The store did have the RD skates marked down pretty low though. The sonics were going for $99, the SCoast for $170ish, and the TK4000s for like $240. The next brand was Bauer The Bauer naming is kinda confusing with all those X's 8-) but anyway... X/3 ($120 list): All laces, shiny grey boot with black in places. 70mm wheels. Probably 78A. We didn't try these on, but hey, they're the low end skates, go figure. XF/3,Freestyle ($180 list): All laces, shiny grey boot with black, 72mm 78A wheels. Again we didn't try these out, but looks like it was comparable to the Lightning 608s or Zetra303s (I know, there's a difference, but just as a guess.) XS/5,Street ($200 list): All laces again, with a shiny black boot. Came with neon yellow 72mm 78A wheels too. My friend tried them out. Good liner, but laces are laces and they take time so my friend kinda said "nah..." 8-) Anyway, a good skate, good bearings, good fit. XT/7,Trainer ($300 list): This skate was amazing. (Well, after trying the Rollerderby skates, these were relatively amazing 8-). The boot is shiny black, cut low with laces and a great buckle on the cuff. Wheels were 72mm 78A, the bearings were Germans I believe. The liner was like sinking your feet into a pillow. Very cushy, very snug. As much as I hate to admit it 8-), the liners were probably better than my Aeroblade liners. Even rolling around on the carpeted floor, the skates felt *very* fast. If they weren't so durn expensive, I'd grab a pair. One important thing to notice is that the front wheel is set a good deal forward, even farther than the Aeroblade front wheel is. The front wheel's bolt is practically under the front end of the boot. Good for speed I suppose, but definitely a different feel from all the other skates. It was really too bad this Pelican store didn't have Racers (like the another one did) so I could compare. The Bauer skates all had rubbery brakes, slanted at an angle so that you could effectively lift your brake foot to lift. Rollerblade brakes, when new are parallel to the ground, which makes it a tad bit harder to brake easily. The Bauer brakes were a little thin though. About half as thick as Rollerblade brakes, so they might wear faster. Anyway, hope this little review is useful to people looking to buy skates. Note: the prices above are probably on the high side. Pelican is notorious for outrageous prices, so you'd probably be able to get a pretty good deal at other stores. (When we have time, we'll head out to the other and better Pelican store. They not only have the entire Rollerblade line-up, in every color, but they also have Ultra Wheels and SwitcHits skates.) -Tony Chen adchen@lee.cs.uiowa.edu ----- Y'all ready for some Bauer hype and jargon? 8-) I got the Bauer brochure a couple of weeks ago. Why didn't I think of copying every word down for you folks to read? (NO comments 8-) 8-) I'll provide a quick chart on the XF/3, XS/5, XT/7 and XR/10s. SKATE : WHEEL/BRNGS : CHASSIS : LINER : SHELL MATERIAL : : : : XF/3 : 70mm82A/NMB : superlight : high density : molded polyurethane : Bauer : glass-filled : foam : : : : : XS/5 : 72mm78A/NMB : superlight : Evazote/Volara : molded polyurethane : Hypers : glassfilled : Foam (don't : : : : ask me) : : : : : XT/7 : 72mm78A/GMN : superlight : Evazote/Volara : molded polyurethane : Hypers : glassfilled : Foam : : : : : XR/10 : 76mm78A/GMN : Zandstra : Memory foam : molded polyurethane : Hypers : 6000 : : So the verdict is...if you're comparing the XF/3 and the XS/5, the only real difference are the wheels and bearings! I don't know about Bauer's penchant for over-hyped-marketing names for their liners. Is there a major difference in liner qualities between the XF/3 and XS/5? Probably only a minimal amount. If you find XF/3s for a good deal less than XS/5s you're probably getting a good bargain. -Tony Chen, adchen@lee.cs.uiowa.edu ----- California Pros --------------- From: markb@plasma.kinetics.com (Mark Burnham) Date: Wed, 6 Nov 1991 23:25:00 GMT I recently purchased a pair of CaliforniaPro Inline skates. I have the "top" model called the "Nitroline". I only paid $150 for them at Nordstrum's (NOT the cheapest place around) in San Francisco. They are basically a RollerBlade Lightning TRS clone. They have laces and a single buckle at the top of the boot. The wheels are 70mm/78A very similar to the TRS wheels. I've skated in them now for probably about 16 hours (not all at once!) and I'm really happy with them. A friend of mine has the TRS's and I seem to be able to roll just as quickly as him. I think they are the best value on the market (that I've seen). The only difference I can see between the Nitroline and the TRS is that the TRS boot may be slightly stiffer, and a bit more plush. I called CaliforniaPro about using 72mm wheels and they said it was no problem (that's the largest you can go however). The phone rang about 3 times and someone answered and gave me the information I was looking for. I was really impressed. That sort of response is pretty rare. I don't know about other places in the country, but 72mm wheels are much more common than 70mm around here. Also, according to a friend who knows, the bearings in the wheels (NMB 608's) are "pretty good". I don't know nothing 'bout bearings, so I'll take his word for it. That said, I've seen 1 small problem: It's a pain to find someplace to get brakes. The store I bought them from doesn't carry the damn things. I've made an interesting discovery however. The TRS brake assembly bolts right on! There is a slight difference between the 2 systems, but it seemed quite secure when I bolted on the TRS assembly. I haven't skated on this yet, so I can't guarantee that it works, but it seems like it'll be fine. The RollerBlade brake systems use much more material in the brakes, so I'm sure they'll last longer then the stock CaliforniaPro ones (the CaliforniaPro brakes are cylindrical, kinda like those funky skates with 2 wheels on each side of the boot. ;) ). I'm planning to get a TRS assembly soon and really skate on it. I'll let you know what happens. Anyway, if anyone is looking for good reasonably priced skates, I would strongly recommend the CaliforniaPro Nitroline skate. BTW, they do have a cheaper model (like ~$90) but it lacks the buckle, and unfortunately I don't remember what sort of wheels it had. CaliforniaPro can be reached at: 10637 Roselle St., Suite G San Diego, CA 92121 (619) 597-0690 (619) 597-0776 - FAX Have fun. BTW, I have no affiliation with CaliforniaPro. -Mark (markb@wc.novell.com) ----- From: Thomas.Sullivan@cs.cmu.edu Message-ID: <4dADMGC00aPCQbjlhl@cs.cmu.edu> Date: 25 Nov 91 13:09:38 GMT Organization: Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PA I test drove my new Gretzky Wings this past Saturday in a hockey game. They roll very smoothly and the boot is quite comfortable. The lower part of the skate laces and the upper part has the ski boot style buckle. This makes for a very snug ankle fit. I would recommend these buckle styles for any skaters that really like a snug fit. One of the things I didn't like about my last pair of skates was that it was hard to pull the laces very tight with the plastic boots. I like my hockey (ice) skates very tight and snug (like they're a part of my feet), and the buckle really allows for that feel on the inline. Since I'm still pretty much a greenhorn at inline skating, I've got a few things to learn about stopping in a hockey game! Especially now with skates with very fast bearings. I love the fact that I can corner much better with the Wings than my older skates, and the speed and smoothness is much closer to ice now too, but ya just can't hockey stop in an inline like you do on ice (and I keep forgetting that!). Any other inline hockey players have comments on stopping style? I also removed the brake from my skate about midway through the game, and it made turning around to skate backwards much easier. I kept catching the brake sometimes when I'd turn around. I don't recommend skating without a brake around town (hills and such) but on a flat surface during a hockey game, not a bad idea. I also found that I could turn more easily by pivoting on the front wheels instead of the whole skate. Might be able to retain the brake if I perfect this technique more. The liner in the Wings is also very comfortable. Pretty thick foam so even when the skate is tight, you don't feel like it is digging into your foot. I'm pretty happy with the skate so far. Oh yeah, we were playing hockey on a tennis court. Great surface, pretty smooth (although ours here at Carnegie Mellon have some major cracks in them) so you roll nicely, and don't shred yourself when you fall, but rough enough that you can really hug the surface on turns. --Tom P.S. The Wings are also on sale now at the Great Skate for $170. This is a *GREAT* price. I paid $183 at Sabreland for mine, which is the best "regular" price I found. I didn't get my Great Skate sale catalog until a few days after I had already ordered them from Sabreland. If anyone is interested in a fast, comfortable skate, I'd recommend looking into these. Enjoy! P.P.S. They also give you this really cheezy video of them making an UltraWheels video with Gretzky. A real selling point! (HA) ----- The Reviews section of the October issue of Outside has an excellent article about in-lines. The writer reviews skates he likes from Ultra Wheels, SwitcHit, Bauer, Riedell, and Rollerblade. He also describes the nature of learning new things on skates: you often will find that you learn new skills instantly -- or will find that you already know how to do something, but won't discover it until The Moment of Trial. I won't spoil the stories he tells, but I do think he embellished his Boulder Creek Trail story a bit--I don't think I've ever hit 40MPH on the section of trail mentioned on my Racers. Perhaps 30. That's fast enough. It is a fun little section of trail, provided that few other users are around. The writer strongly states that lateral support is mandatory. This is not necessarily true. Good racers prefer to have their ankles free for more power on the stroke. World-class skaters -- both quad and in-line -- will use boots that are cut very low. However, substantial lateral support is very useful for almost all non-racing types. My other gripe, a small one, is that I view the RacerBlade as an excellent commuting skate, not necessarily as only a beginner's racing skate. If you're mainly interested in getting from Point A to B and already have some experience, don't ignore the "Racer". All in all, an excellent article. Some good ideas for folks who want to try something other than Rollerblade skates. Check it out. Phil Earnhardt pae@netwise.com Netwise, Inc. Boulder, CO (303) 442-8280 SWITCH-IT REVIEWS ----------------- Switchit's address is: Innovative Sport Systems, Inc. 6507 Cecilia Circle Minneapolis, Mn 55439 Some of the SwitchIts features are nice. Both my roomates have Switch-its, but have had some problems: 1) They have the lace up (not buckle ones), and they have an extremely though time getting them tight, and keeping them tight. I've never seen the buckle version (probably the SwIt high end). 2) One pair came with very short axels, which weren't quite long enough, and he had a wheel pop off while skating. Very dangerous. SwIt sent him a new set of axels (where the threads came all the way though the bolts, not just 1/2 way), and appologized, but I have to question their quality control, and commitment to safety for ever shipping crap like this. 3) My one roomate and I do a lot of jumps and he's having problems with the plastic hubs of his wheels crumbling. Overall the wheels don't seem to hold up under *heavy* stress. I didn't really like the long wheelbase, or the fact that there is a un-removeable brake stop on each side. I also liked the top buckle on the TRS. ----- Yeah, I looked at SwitchIts, but: * Their homegrown wheels looked cheap and flimsy. * The "Laceless" model only has two buckles -- in fact it has lace holes so you can use both. * They weren't all that comfortable * They weren't all that cheap * I don't do Ice right now, and as has been pointed out, swapping left and right runners is not an adequate way of rotating your wheels. But on the positive side: * I like the long wheelbase (back wheel farther back) and big wheels * It has a little thingy to keep the liner heel from coming up off the heel of the boot while you skate * They're lighter than a lot of skates (but not nearly as light as Aeros) Can anyone tell us about the Reidell 601 Extreme? I've heard this is a good skate. David B Rosen, Cognitive & Neural Systems Internet: rosen@cns.bu.edu ----- I have a pair of SwitchIts. They're nice skates, and certainly better than the standard hired RB's. I tried on a pair of Macros, but didn't like them. I haven't tried the AeroBlades yet (but if I like them, I may get a pair of them too). The SwitchIts are nice for these reasons: 1. Most people have RB's, and I like to be different. 2. They're good if you like Ice as well. 3. Swapping wheels is very simple -- just swap all 4 at once 4. No LACES! This is the single best feature for me. The velcro straps on some brands seem a little flimsy, and I don't like doing up laces. I love the plastic bindings 5. Mounting system allows you to retrofit your most comfortable existing boots for SwitchIts. Useful for experienced skaters. 6. Very comfortable, and seem to be light ( but I haven't seen any Aeros yet). Good ankle support. 7. There's an inner boot which may be easily removed and washed. Against: 8. The brake mountings extend a little too far back for my liking. Even if you remove the brakes, the mounts could get in the way during cross overs or when going down steps fast. 9. The wheel base is a little long for sharp turns, spins or trix. 10. The boot can get a bit sweaty after 5 hours of skating.. :-) 11. There was only one color, a hideous bright orange, in my size. Some other brands use brighter colors. Paul Gillingwater, paul@actrix.gen.nz From: paul@actrix.gen.nz (Paul Gillingwater) Message-ID: <1992Jan16.193117.12357@actrix.gen.nz> Date: 16 Jan 92 19:31:17 GMT I'm a SwitchIt owner. I like them. > 1) Brakes are significantly smaller than other skates. True, they give > you two brakes, but neither brake frame is removable! The smallish > brake pads have less stopping power and wear faster than other > manufacturer's brakes Yes, they do wear faster. The frame isn't removable, which can be a hassle when going forwards down steps. > 2) Only two buckles on the Switchit 1141. Can you offer enough support > with only two buckles? Wear not talking some rear-entry ski boot here. > In fact there are still holes so you can use laces for additional > tightening. I find that two can give enough support, at least for my needs. I have trouble with laces... :-) > 3) Hubcaps on the wheels have been known to simply crumble, although > this is due to higher-than-normal stress. IMHO, hubcaps, although > providing some scrape protection seems like just adding to the menage of > wheel-geer parts. Yep. I have lost most of my hubcaps as a result of scrapes and bangs. > BUT, as much as I slam Switchits, there are many GOOD points: > > 1) Long wheel base of 11.5 inches, good for a little more stabilty > if you need it (i.e. don't do a lot of tricks/spins...) and can take > 76mm wheels. They're FAST too -- but that's the wheels I guess. > 2) Although the brake *frame* is not removable, the brake pads > themselves are changeable withOUT tools. A big plus when you're on the > go. Quite right too. Just unscrew them by hand. > 3) Ability to swap wheels quickly (although, as it's been pointed out, > this isn't as useful as it seems, since wheel rotation should include > changing positions too). This can be a benefit if you're lazy (like moi). > 4) The only skate on the market to let you swap the rollerblade for a > ice hockey blade. (However, real ice hockey skates never have a hard > urethane shell because it's too stiff. As far as I can tell, ice hockey > players would rather have a soft leather shell for flexibility.) Quite right -- in fact one of the biggest drawbacks is the boot. But SwitchIt mechs (i.e. the heel plate) can be retrofitted to most pro leather boots. This is a big plus. Paul Gillingwater, paul@actrix.gen.nz From: rice@gambln.enet.dec.com (Tim Rice) Message-ID: <1992Jan17.151542.13919@ryn.mro4.dec.com> Date: Fri, 17 Jan 1992 15:15:42 GMT I owned a pair of the Micron hockey skates back around '80. I grew up on Bauer skates (Black Panthers, 92's, etc.). When I got into my 20's my feet were too wide for Bauer's anymore (to much trouble with in-grown toenails). The Microns are the urethane (plastic) boot with an ICM blade. They were a nice skate except that motion side to side was too restrictive. The boot didn't pivot enough in that direction so I would "often" lose an edge and wind up on my butt. This finally happened once during a game where I got hurt, I went head first into the boards. The skates were retired just after that. Other than that the boot was great. It provided many advantages over a leather boot. One I didn't see you mention was that it distributes the shock from a puck much better than leather. Again this is speaking from experience since I had some toes broken in this fashion. After experimenting with different skates I'd buy leather because it is still the best all around. The only real disadvantages to leather are the break in and down aspects. They provide the most control. The next problem is in finding a leather skate. I stay away from synthetics as much as possible. I prefer GRAF skates. The break in period is very short. The break down period is also short (downside). It is a very comfortable boot and provides the most control I've found. They are rather expensive 200+ for a hockey skate, considering they won't last 3 years. An active high school type player may only get one year out of them. For someone my age they're perfect, I get 3 years out of a pair. It's about time for my third. END SWITCHIT REVIEWS ----- MACRO BLADES EQ/ES From: gwm@spl1.spl.loral.com (Gary W. Mahan) Subject: MacroBlade Equipes Review I recently bought a pair of Macroblade Equipes(the new model). I thought I would give a little review on them as I have not seen any yet. My main reason for buying the Equipe was shoe size. I really wanted the AeroBlades (for weight savings) but the biggest size was a 12.5 and I have a size 13 foot. Several people in this group recommended that I try the Aeros. Well I did and they were way too narrow. The Equipe boot will accomodate wider feet much better. I ended up getting the Equipe in a 30.5 (biggest size available). I have seen several postings comparing Aeros to Equipes. From what I have read, most seem to think that Equipes are not rockerable like the Aeros. Well the Equipes I have seem to have the same rockering combinations as the Aeros. Also the Equipes have ratcheting buckles like the Aeros. The buckles on the Equipes seemed a little better. The largest wheel that will fit is supposedly a 77 mm as opposed to 80 for the Aeros(Supposedly). The skates were equipped with 76mm 76A hyper wheels (Small hub). The bearings were ABEC1 made in singapore (same as on my lightning TRS's). The Equipes have a cuff which allows some forward movement. However it is not hinged like a Aero. This is still hard to get use to. I almost fell backward several times because of this (although this may have been for other reasons (wheel positioning)). I consider the ankle support to be excellent compared to my lightnings. The Equipes also seem to have wheel positioning similar to the Aeros (i.e the front whell is more forward). The front axle is lined up with the front of the boot. The liners are very comfortable although memory foam is not used. There are holes in the liners for ventilation but these do not extend all the way through the foam. The skates are vented like Aero's although not as much. The skates have tremendously increased my skating ability (as opposed to lightning TRS's). I seem to be able to go much faster now. At high speeds I do not seem to have the skates wobble as much (eventhough the wheelbase difference is less than an inch). My gliding ability (1 foot) has also increased dramatically, allowing more efficient strokes. The price on the Macroblades was $279 (Aeros were $289). METROBLADES ----------- From: gt0258f@prism.gatech.EDU (James Garvey) Subject: Re: MetroBlades - review requested In article <1993May11.221207.731@news.uiowa.edu> thieleke@icaen.uiowa.edu (Jeffrey Ray Thieleke) writes: > >I'm looking for people's opinions on MetroBlades - good and bad. Specifically, >I'm interested in performance and comfort. > I sent out a request for info on metroblades about 2 months ago and really didn't get much of a response. My friend is getting ready to buy a pair in New York City and he told me that the big problem is support around the ankles. Rollerblade puts them in their "sport" category which is supposed to be for "thrashing". I'm not sure how much trashing you want to do in a boot like the Metroblade. Anyway, the general consensus was get a pair of sandals or lightweight shoes and buy a pair of skates with buckles. Then buy a fanny pack or something like that to carry your shoes while you skate. Get yourself a ski boot strap (handle with a loop of nylon) and carry your skates like ski boots. Most sports stores will give you a ski boot handle for free. Here's a few of the replies regarding the Metroblade. (Tony, I'm not sure if you'd want to include these or not, but here they are for your review). (original post) >I have a friend that is getting ready to buy a pair of inline skates and is >considering buying Rollerblade Metroblades. This is the skate that has a >built in boot inside of it that lets you "walk" out of the skate. He's >not planning on doing a lot of heavy duty skating, just to and from work. >I would say that stalling and rail sliding would definitely be out! > >His main concern is not having to carry around a pair of shoes when he >skates. Does anyone know anything about these skates? I own a pair and am very happy with them, commuting to and from university and generally around town. _I_ might recommend them, but they're the only skates I've used for extended amounts of time (i.e., non-rentals), so I don't have much to compare them with. I've heard other skaters (on this board, in person, and in Inline magazine) complain that they're not really up to snuff... that Rollerblade made too many performance degradations to get the design to work. The design _does_ work, though. The shoes are comfortable both inside the skates (though it hurts for a few days getting used to how tight it needs to be to minimize wobble) and outside them (I've hiked in the shoes.. no problem. They look like they'll last quite a while too). Getting into and out of the skates is fast and easy. On the other hand, even folded up the skate shell is heavy and unwieldy, perhaps not as much as whole blades, but they can't be stuffed in a backpack unless the backpack's pretty empty (btw, Rollerblade is offering a free backpack -- a $50 value! *snort* -- to purchasers of Metroblades. I haven't gotten mine yet, but I suppose the pack could be designed to carry the blade shell easily). If your friend is planning to use the skates for organized recreation (i.e. hockey or half-pipes), or even for getting a bit radical during the commute, probably a one-piece skate and a light pair of shoes would be a better idea. I'm happy with my pair, and wouldn't trade them in for anything, but then I always wished I had a pair of key-roller-skates or a fold-up-bike when I was younger. I like to be portable. -eh ------------------------------------------------------------------ erik hilsdale eh@cs.columbia.edu Word is that these are a clever idea, but the compromise is that you may not get the best skate for the money you pay. It they guys is fixed on it it's probably survivable. Is he an experienced skater, or just a beginner trying to plan his fate? The alternative would be a good 3-buckle skate that is very quick to pop on/off and pair of really lightweight shoes he can carry in a fanny pack or other tote. There are some lightweight (soft sole) cycle shoes and some that are even lighter for swimmers or something like that. George Robbins - now working for, work: to be avoided at all costs... >The alternative would be a good 3-buckle skate that is very quick to >pop on/off and pair of really lightweight shoes he can carry in a fanny >pack or other tote. There are some lightweight (soft sole) cycle shoes >and some that are even lighter for swimmers or something like that. This has been my solution - I have a pair of Teva sandals that I wear when I'm off the blades, and they work pretty well - I carry them around in my fanny pack. I also have a loop of nylon cord with a handle on it for carrying the skates when I'm wearing the sandals. There's also an over-the-shoulder carry strap that you can get for rollerblades, but I haven't tried it, so I don't know how well it works... _MelloN_ -- mellon@ncd.com uunet!lupine!mellon Member of the League for Programming Freedom. To find out how software patents may cost you your right to program, contact lpf@uunet.uu.net From: eh@cs.columbia.edu (Erik Hilsdale) Subject: Re: RB Metroblades: good, bad, or ugly? In article <91390@hydra.gatech.EDU> gt0258f@prism.gatech.EDU (James Andrew Garvey) writes: >I have a friend that is getting ready to buy a pair of inline skates and is >considering buying Rollerblade Metroblades. This is the skate that has a >built in boot inside of it that lets you "walk" out of the skate. He's >not planning on doing a lot of heavy duty skating, just to and from work. >I would say that stalling and rail sliding would definitely be out! > >His main concern is not having to carry around a pair of shoes when he >skates. Does anyone know anything about these skates? I own a pair and am very happy with them, commuting to and from university and generally around town. _I_ might recommend them, but they're the only skates I've used for extended amounts of time (i.e., non-rentals), so I don't have much to compare them with. I've heard other skaters (on this board, in person, and in Inline magazine) complain that they're not really up to snuff... that Rollerblade made too many performance degradations to get the design to work. The design _does_ work, though. The shoes are comfortable both inside the skates (though it hurts for a few days getting used to how tight it needs to be to minimize wobble) and outside them (I've hiked in the shoes.. no problem. They look like they'll last quite a while too). Getting into and out of the skates is fast and easy. On the other hand, even folded up the skate shell is heavy and unwieldy, perhaps not as much as whole blades, but they can't be stuffed in a backpack unless the backpack's pretty empty (btw, Rollerblade is offering a free backpack -- a $50 value! *snort* -- to purchasers of Metroblades. I haven't gotten mine yet, but I suppose the pack could be designed to carry the blade shell easily). If your friend is planning to use the skates for organized recreation (i.e. hockey or half-pipes), or even for getting a bit radical during the commute, probably a one-piece skate and a light pair of shoes would be a better idea. I'm happy with my pair, and wouldn't trade them in for anything, but then I always wished I had a pair of key-roller-skates or a fold-up-bike when I was younger. I like to be portable. AEROBLADE REVIEWS ----------------- By the way, I love my new Aeros. Much better glide than the Lightnings I had been using (rental loaners). Something I thought was extra neat, although I haven't taken advantage of it yet, is that the rockering SLOTS are offset. This allows a flat blade, a shallow rocker, a deep rocker, and combinations. What do I mean? This is the flat blade setup. --- --- | | --- --- | | |x| |x| |x| |x| --- | | | | --- --- --- I don't know, maybe this is an old idea, and the Aeros aren't first, but I *love* this kind of design detail! ----- I have a pair of Aeroblades. Here are my comments: On the plus side: * Boots very lightweight as mentioned. * Ventilation good. * Allows you to bend forward a lot. (And not side to side, fortunately.) * Boot positions shin tilted forward more than some other skates -- encourages you to bend knees more -- a good position for skating * Big wheels (76mm) * ratchet buckles are pretty good * lightweight but strong frames (runners) End-on view of frames (very schematic): Aero Other _______ _______ \# #/ | | \ / | | | | | | Cons: * The buckles don't "remember" your previous setting when you remove them like the Macroblade ones do. But you can always mark it with a felt tip pen I suppose. * The brake is like that on the lightnings and macroblade, but it is made of "a new composite material" that SQUEALS LIKE HELL WHEN YOU BRAKE. Scares the daylights out of unsuspecting pedestrians. Rollerblade told me this would stop when the brake pad was broken in, but it hasn't. I just bought a lightning replacement pad -- I hope this cures the problem. * I've had some trouble with the fit to my feet. These seem to be narrower than my old rollerblades. They should really offer both D and E widths like Bauer does. It may also be that three buckles and a very thin boot can't support the whole foot all that well. * The place where the tongue overlaps with the rest of the liner digs two ridges into my foot. Also the footbed (insole) they come with is fairly uncomfortable and non-anatomically-shaped. * They seem to have missed some places that need ventilation. the areas under the tongue and and the front and back of my ankles still get quite sweaty. * On some skates the two parts of some of the buckles do not line up quite parallel -- this could lead to premature wear or slipping. * Some were shipped with wobbly wheels (non-true) -- but your Rollerblade dealer should replace them for you if you bring them back in. Also the wheels are not centered with respect to the bearings, and they have a cheap-looking part on where I guess they were cut out of their mold during manufacturing. Makes me want Hyper Wheels. * Wheels aren't as light as the newer wheels from Hyper and Kryptonics. * I've decided I like softer wheels, to handle those bumps more gracefully. Aeros are 78A so maybe my old Zetra 608s had 74A? But I don't know of any inlines that come with softer than 78A nowadays. Maybe I'll splurge on some new wheels. * Front wheel is further forward than on other skates. This is okay for the experienced skater but I don't recommend it for a beginner because this can make the skate unstable if you put your weight forward onto it. This may make the skate faster for racing, but it also makes more leverage that tends to lift your heel inside the boot, so proper fit becomes even more important. I think they should have moved all four wheels back a little (maybe 1/4 inch), since having the back wheel back a little improves stability. * I don't like the color options -- can't they offer something more low key so people outside of California aren't embarrassed to be seen in it? :-) * NMB 608Z bearings (made in singapore). I have heard that these are not as good as the GMN 608Z german bearings that at least used to come in the Lightnings. Not that I've noticed any difference in performance myself. * Back of the brake sticks out a little more than I think is necessary, which can get in the way of crossovers if you're not careful. * The frame spacer / bearing spacer / axle system is poorly designed. It does not hold the wheel quite straight, and it seems to bind the bearings a little when you tighten the bolts a lot, which you have to do to prevent the wheel from slipping up and down a little during skating. Before tightening there is too much play and the frame spacer does not properly meet the bearing -- one of them starts to slide off of the the other on one side. I don't know why, but the one pair of Lightnings I looked at were better than the Aeros in this respect, even though they *appear* to have the same parts for this. Phil Earnhardt says Reidell has a superior spacer system. I used to have the old metal-runner Zetra 608, which held the center of the bearing via metal washers and spacers, and worked much better in that way. They should make the inner diameter of the frame and bearing spacers smaller to match the axle, and the frame spacers and the inner part of the bearing spacers (which holds the two bearings apart) should be made of aluminum instead of plastic. I hope somebody at Rollerblade reads this. David B Rosen, Cognitive & Neural Systems Internet: rosen@cns.bu.edu ----- David B. Rosen writes: >I have a pair of Aeroblades. Here are my comments: > >* The brake is like that on the lightnings and macroblade, but it is >made of "a new composite material" that SQUEALS LIKE HELL WHEN YOU >BRAKE. Scares the daylights out of unsuspecting pedestrians. It is pretty effective, though, at getting those dim-wits who don't know what "on your left" means to move off the path... :-) >* I've had some trouble with the fit to my feet. These seem to be >narrower than my old rollerblades. They should really offer both D >and E widths like Bauer does. It may also be that three buckles and a >very thin boot can't support the whole foot all that well. Same here. I've got relatively wide feet, and I'm just hoping that, over time, my liners will compress a bit and my boots will stretch just a bit to fit my feet better. >* The place where the tongue overlaps with the rest of the liner digs >two ridges into my foot. Also the footbed (insole) they come with is >fairly uncomfortable and non-anatomically-shaped. Of all things, my heels are uncomfortable in my Aeroblades. It feels as though I'm putting far too much pressure on them. Has anyone else experienced this? >* I don't like the color options -- can't they offer something more >low key so people outside of California aren't embarrassed to be seen >in it? :-) Ditto! I'm all for basic black... -JC, jc@msc.edu ----- The only suggestion I have is buy the best skates you can possibly afford--and maybe even a pair that you can't REALLY afford, but by scrimping somewhere else you can do it. Or, alternatively, buy a cheaper pair of skates but outfit them with high performance wheels and A-grade bearings before you even hit the pavement (that is probably the best solution, if you haven't got a lot of money). I bought a pair of Rollerblade Zetra 303s in May on a whim. They cost $150, and I didn't want to "spend to much on something I might not stick with." Well, I didn't know it at the time but those skates were inhibiting me, and within 20-30 miles the el-cheapo C-grade bearings had melted down and left me with an inoperative pair of blades. Two months later I finally got around to calling the shop where I got the skates to find out about getting them repaired under warrantee. They said it would take 8-10 weeks while they shipped them to Minnesota, determined if it was really a warantee repair, and then shipped them back--and there was no guarantee they wouldn't charge me for the repair if they thought it was "my own fault." Well, in 8-10 weeks there will be snow on the ground up here, so I was a little upset. I went out and bought a pair of AeroBlades ($300) in a fit of pique, and man I should have done that in the first place! All I can say is, for twice the money you get three times the blade. The fast wheels and bearings have a lot to do with it, but the buckle (as opposed to lace) closure system is a dream. A medium-priced alternative are the Lightnings, which have buckle closures but not the fancy chassis. I'll shut up and let someone who really knows what they're talking about advise you, but I'll stick by the "best you can afford" recommendation. Andy, ANDY@MAINE.MAINE.EDU END AEROBLADE REVIEWS = RACING SKATES REVIEWS = In article <13914@aggie.ucdavis.edu> bunds@jade.ucdavis.edu writes: >Can anyone give me information on brands of 5-wheel skates, besides >racerblades, that are available? I'd very much appreciate any info at >all. > >M. P. Bunds, U. C. Davis The good news is that there are models from many different manufacturers. I have heard of models from Bauer, SwitcHit, Riedell, Rollerblade (Racerblade plus the Pro Racer), Viking (A very good European ice speed-skating manufacturer), Bont (Australian ice), etc. There also is a movement for manufacturers to sell racing boots with a pair of threaded bolts to attach either blades or runners for wheels. Yeah! Standardization! The bad news is that I've never seen anything other than the Racer in retail markets.You're going to have to either travel to someone who sells the skates or do it via mail-order. Marty Hill of Built for Speed sells stuff out of his house in Syracuse, NY. Dave of SMR sports ((708) 387-0283) does the same out of Riverside, IL. SoH ((800) 554-1235) was planning to sell the SwitcHit 5-wheeler when it became available. If at all possible, I'd go in person to one of these stores and make sure you find someone knowledgable about the long skates. You might be leary of SoH, since they appear to have a pretty cozy arrangement with SwitcHit. Have you tried the Racer? It's a bit on the heavy end for a 5-wheeler, but is very robust and probably a good skate to start out on racing. (Heck, any of the faster 4-wheelers are fine, too!) Some Rollerblade demo vans have the Racer available; you can try a pair there. Some very good racers are winning races on the Racerblade. One other piece of good news: Rod Murillo, a member of Team Krypto, is now reading alt.skate. Welcome! He's far more qualified to talk about racing than I am; he might have some suggestions for you. Phil Earnhardt pae@netwise.com ----- From: betsy@alf.sybase.com Date: 13 Nov 91 23:06:25 GMT I got some new racing skates about 2 months ago. I love them!!! I tryed on Zanstras and Racerblades. Looked into Bauer and leather boots (from Built for Speed). After all my looking...I bought Ultras from Sventech in Seattle (sold by Ultra). Here are thoughts that might help others who are looking at racing skates. Zanstras There are three problems with Zanstras, from my point of view. Firstly, the bearings "seem" really cheap. They aren't as smooth as I would like and they make too much noise. Secondly, the boot is really uncomfortable. A number of racers have complained that they bind the top of their feet too much. In fact, some people cut out the sizes of their boots. I found this true when I tryed them on. Finally, my size (6-6 1/2) only comes with four wheels....great why buy racing skates. The good thing about Zanstras is that they are pretty light. Racerblades The Racerblades are really comfortable! It's like riding in pillows. However, it's also like using a limo in a road race. They felt too big and heavy (though I don't really remember their weight). Once I felt the weight, I knocked them off the list...so I can't comment on the bearings or wheels. Bauer As with the Zanstras, the Bauers don't have 5 wheels in my size. However, the boot looked really comfortable. I knocked them out as soon as I heard about the wheel limit. Leather Boots Sorry...I may be into skating....but I would like to try and stay out of the poor house. I was looking at spending $700 to $800 for leather boots. Maybe if I ever get close to beating Karen Edwards or the other top women skaters, I'll think about it...but I think that will take more than just new skates. Ultras The Ultras have a titanium frame. The lengths come in 13, 14 and 15 inches. The boots are very comfortable (I can usually keep them on for three hours before they bother me). The boot fit is like the Racerblades with a buckle and wide fit, but the shell is very light. The boot can be molded to your foot with a dryer or hot water. In a rough estimate, with 5 wheels they are about the same weight as my 4 wheel Rollerblade 608s. I guess what finally made the sale..was Bancroft hill in Berkeley. I can jam down Bancroft without any shaking. The ride is very smooth. The bearings are smooth and fast. By the by...they come with Hyper Wheeles. The only problem is...no brake. So, I may not need it for racing....but I would like one for working out. Berkeley drivers don't know what to do with a skater. I guess my advise is...try on everything (in your price range). Some people swear by skates I rejected. What everyone is looking for in a skate is different. I wanted good low weight racing skates. Still plowing down hills.... betsy By-the-by, does anyone know of something to put on road rash (second skin or the likes)? ----- From: Donn Baumgartner, donn@dell.dell.com I can recommend the Xandstra Skeelers, which are available locally from Riedel, without hesitation. I have used these skates on the OMRA circuit for the last two years and am very pleased with them. I have the Xandstra 6000 - but got it directly from Walter Xandstra a few years ago when he came to the New York race. I use the Hyper 80mm wheels... and prefer the harder (82A) wheels, but many racers prefer the 78A's and even the 75A's. Personal preference... but the harder wheels hold up a little longer. There are many shops nationally that carry this (and many more) inline skates... such as: Competition Skates Trailways Skate Rental c/o John Skelton c/o Tom Sehlhorst 501 Springville Cr. 611 Palm Bluff Birmingham AL 35215 Clearwater FL 33515 (205) 854-9617 (813) 461-9736 Montrose Skate Shop Skate Escape c/o John McKay c/o Janice Phillips 1406 Stanford 1086 Piedmont Ave Houston TX 77019 Atlanta GA 30309 (713) 528-6102 (404) 892-1292 I've done phone/mail/direct business with every one of these shops... they are all reputable. Competition Skates and Trailways Skate are both run by active members of OMRA (Outdoor Marathon Rollerskating Association), and both John and Tom are racing 'experts' (in some sense). And a final comment... get a subscription to Speedskating Times... for $15/year it's the best thing going. Dave Cooper, Eddy Matzger, and Marty Hill regularly write articles in it. ----- From: mpeters@wtcp.DaytonOH.NCR.COM (Michael Peters) Message-ID: <1149@wtcp.DaytonOH.NCR.COM> Date: 10 Mar 92 13:41:32 GMT las writes: >I'm planning to buy a pair of speed inline skates. Need advice as >to which brand I should purchase. Would like a skate under $350.00. For under $350.00, if it's a racing skate you want, I would check out the Bont skate packages that Special Equipment C0. has to offer. (Phone:508-266-1612) They have Bont Sharkie boots with Zandstra frames, wheels and German bearings for $315. These are leather boots with fiberglass counters that you heat and mold to your foot. This is a much hotter setup for speed than buying a citizen racing skate, that has gobs of padding inside, i.e. Racerblade or Bauer XR-10, besides they're cheaper too. The last I heard the XR-10 may go for $385 and the Rollerblade Pro-Blade $450. The Rollerblade Racerblade is in your range, but it's a bit heavy, though if you don't skate that much, you may like the additional support that the Racerblade gives. Mike.Peters@wtcp.DaytonOH.NCR.COM ...!uunet!ncrcom!wtcp!mpeters Article 2544 of rec.skate: Newsgroups: rec.skate Path: caen!destroyer!wsu-cs!vela!m.cs.uiuc.edu!biske From: biske@cs.uiuc.edu (Todd Biske) Subject: Re: AeroBlades vs. Roces Barcelona model Message-ID: <1992Aug27.025101.23699@m.cs.uiuc.edu> Sender: news@m.cs.uiuc.edu (News Database (admin-Mike Schwager)) Organization: University of Illinois, Dept. of Comp. Sci., Urbana, IL References: <1992Aug26.215318.26669@leland.Stanford.EDU> Date: Thu, 27 Aug 1992 02:51:01 GMT shandley@leland.Stanford.EDU (Simon Handley) writes: >Does anyone know what the difference is between Aeroblades and the >Roces "Barcelona" model? The Barcelona and the Aeros are actually quite a bit different. Roces used to manufacture all RollerBlade boots, but this is no longer the case. RollerBlade boots are now made my Nordica. Anyways, here goes: Similarities: Both boots are vented Both have Memory Foam liners Both use a three buckle system on the boots Both come with 76mm 78A wheels Differences: Aeroblade boot is vented much better. The vents are larger and more numerous. The Aeroblade boot is made from BladeLite (tm) while the Barcelona uses the same material as the CoolBlade (polyurethane?) which results in a 15% heavier boot. Aeros have a graduated brake, can also accept older style RollerBlade brakes. Barcelona uses a custom Roces brake, not commonly available for people in the cornfields of the midwest like myself. Barcelona tends to run $30-$40 cheaper than the Aeros. I just purchased a pair of Aeros from Courtesy Sports in Los Altos (before I drove back to Illinois for school) and did a lot of research on the Roces vs. RollerBlade debate, and I think I bought the better skate. That's an opinion however. My final decision was made when I tried on BOTH skates at Courtesy. Then my mind was made up. -tb -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "Success is to be measured not so much by the position that one has reached in life as by the obstacles which he has overcome while trying to succeed." - Booker T. Washington Todd Biske - U of I Dept. of Computer Science - biske@cs.uiuc.edu - 2434 DCL -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- =END OF PART 5==================================================================